PHIL 309: Twentieth Century Analytic Philosophy

LARKIN: Spring 2003

___________________________________________

 

 

Analytic “Schools”

 

 

School

 

Representative Figures

Critique of Traditional Philosophy

True Function of Philosophy

Analytic Method

Common Sense Realism

Moore

Russell

Too detached from common sense

Make explicit and get deeper understanding of what we know

Analyze the sense of Common Sense Propositions

Logical Atomism

Russell

Wittgenstein

Misled by surface grammatical structure of  ordinary language

Reveal the underlying structure of reality

Use new logic to get at deep logical structure of sentences

Logical Positivism

Ayer

Carnap

Traditional philosophical claims are literally nonsense

Sort statements into the empirically meaningful, the tautological, and the nonsensical

Apply the verification principle to statements, test for tautologies

Ordinary Language Philosophy

Wittgenstein

Austin

Traditional philosophical problems are mere pseudo-problems that result from misuse of language

Dissolve philosophical problems by bringing words back to their ordinary use

Elaborate the use of ordinary language expressions and their role in various ‘forms of life’

Logico-Linguistic Metaphysics

Quine

Davidson

Sellars

Metaphysically Extravagant Theorizing

Weigh common sense manifest image of world against scientific image

Make the commitments of folk theories and language explicit and prime them for comparison to scientific theories

 

 

Common Claims:

 

1.        Traditional Philosophy is too detached from common sense and ordinary language:

  1. Common Sense Realism
  2. Ordinary Language Philosophy

 

2.        Traditional Philosophy is overly speculative and unscientific:

  1. Logical Positivism
  2. Logico-Linguistic Metaphysics

 

3.        Traditional philosophy misuses language in some way:

  1. Logical Atomism
  2. Logical Positivism
  3. Ordinary Language Philosophy

 

4.        We can use new methods to solve traditional philosophical problems:

  1. Common Sense Realism
  2. Logical Atomism
  3. Logico-Linguistic Metaphysics

 

5.        Traditional philosophical problems must be rejected/dissolved:

  1. Logical Positivism
  2. Ordinary Language Philosophy