What constitutes A, B, C, D, or F papers and essays is governed by many factors that vary from assignment to assignment, to be sure, but overall, your writing is evaluated on your commitment to an essay's goals and your audience's needs, as well as your control over your voice in all four of the following categories:
purpose: focus or thesis
development: amplification or support of purpose
order: essay, paragraph, and sentence organization
language: conciseness, usage, sentence construction
The A essay is marked by its originality in ideas and in its creative and logical expression. Consistent control of purpose, voice, and tone, as well as ample development of paragraphs that support the main idea, distinguish the A paper. Reader interest is maintained by details, inventive examples, and thought-provoking reasoning. Cohesiveness and order in the essay structure are managed by the use of appropriate transitions and balanced repetition at essay, paragraph, and sentence level. Finally,the essay's language is concise, sentence constructions are varied and complex, and errors in grammar and mechanics are minimal.
The B essay exhibits above-average ability in statement of purpose, paragraph development, control over voice and tone, organization, and language. As with the A paper, the B paper's purpose or main idea is developed throughout in paragraphs that show a writer's skill in drawing upon more than one writing strategy or device to amplify a topic sentence, such as comparison, analogy, examples, and so on. Critically thought-out ideas also mark the B paper, which demonstrates a writer's ability to use transitional words or phrases to improve narrative flow, to create various kinds of sentences, and to write with conciseness. Errors in grammar and mechanics are minimal.
The C or "passing" essay satisfactorily demonstrates a competent level of writing--its thesis is stated or implied and supported in organized, adequately developed paragraphs. The C essay communicates its main idea in clear, concise language, and is relatively free of grammatical errors.
The D or F paper fails to meet the minimum requirements for an assignment or a passing essay.
The PR grade is assigned to students who have completed all assignments, who have fulfilled the attendance
requirements stated on the teacher's syllabus, and who have made "progress" during the semester, but whose writing has not reached the "C" level by the end of the semester. Students receiving a "PR" must repeat the course, although the grade does NOT affect GPA. You may receive only ONE "PR" grade for ENG 101, and only ONE "PR" grade for ENG 102. If you retake the course and do not get to the "C" level or better, you will receive a "D" or "F."
URL: http://www.siue.edu/ENGLISH/Handbook/grading.html
Published by: Department of English Language and Literature
Last Update: June 20, 2005 by English Web Manager
SIUE