| OF - Jonathan Mercer - Missouri-St. Louis
| OF - Jason Negron - Saint Joseph's
| OF - Kevin Reynolds - Quincy
| OF- Matt Keener - Southern Indiana
| OF - Casey Garms - Wisconsin-Parkside
| OF - Ryan Kuhlman - Bellarmine
| OF - Noah Wetzel - Southern Indiana
| OF - Sean McBride - Saint Joseph's
| C - Andy Sweet - Lewis
| C - Jay Pitts - Bellarmine
| SP - Derrick Moeves - Northern Kentucky
| SP - Chad Kauffman - Indianapolis
| SP - Brandon Kellbach - Wisconsin-Parkside
| SP - Ron Jones - SIU Edwardsville
| SP - Adam Gautreau - Kentucky Wesleyan
| SP - Matt Wiedeman - Northern Kentucky
| SP - Brad Drewes - Missouri-St. Louis
| SP - Jason Bibelhauser - Bellarmine
| RP - Justin Seiter - Northern Kentucky
| RP - Donny Leicht - Wisconsin-Parkside
| | | | | | | | | |
